[Artemis]

Originally Posted by ssquared

Never.
BMW knows the odds of something breaking better than you and they price the warranty accordingly. They are making a profit on it so most people who are buying it are losing. They are capitalizing off of the asymmetry if information they have vs what we have.
Warranty is like insurance. It’s to cover you for losses you can’t afford to cover yourself. If you can afford an M2 you can afford repairs in the unlikely event that you’ll have an issue.

I guess that you're overlooking the human factor. AFAIK, BMW itself and your dealership are even more appreciative about customers that walk the extra mile by getting extended warranty. If a car got extended warranty, it's usually mentioned on the worksheets each time the car is serviced (but customers normally don't get to see those docs). Beware: even with extended warranty a lot of things remain uncovered. But, it could be of influence for eventual commercial gestures granted by BMW to a dealer in favor of a customer (courtesy deals: repairs that are normally not covered, but they fix you a deal for parts and/or labor - less questions asked).

Though you may think that this aspect is arbitrary, it has value. You can use it as argument: "OK, you tell me that there is no warranty for this issue, but I'm an extended warranty customer - please ask BMW to fix me a deal."