This video just happened to come up in my YouTube feed. With UK winter conditions being fairly similar to here, his conclusion seemed relevant to us as well.
https://youtu.be/bKtnczk8Mxk
If you don’t want to watch, conclusion is to use a summer tire in the summer, and an all season tire in the winter for best all around dry and wet performance with some ability in the off chance we get snow, but better in cold and wet, non-snowy conditions that we’re most of the winter season driving in.